When to Implement a Leadership Change for Business Growth

Article By
James Cumming
James Cumming
Posted On13th February 2024

A senior leadership team plays a pivotal role in guiding an organisation towards success. Sometimes to achieve this success, a change of leadership at the top becomes necessary. Identifying this moment is crucial for the sustained health and growth of any company. Here, we explore the indicators that suggest it’s time to consider a change in your senior leadership team.

1. Stagnation in Performance

Business stagnation in performance refers to a period where a company experiences little to no growth.

Key performance indicators (KPIs) such as revenue, profit margins, market share, or other significant metrics, will show this.

This plateau can signal underlying issues that may lead to long-term detrimental effects on the company’s health and success.

A clear sign that a change may be needed is a noticeable stagnation or decline in the company’s performance. This could manifest as consistent underachievement of financial targets, loss of market share, or a decline in productivity.

Fluctuations in performance are normal, a persistent downward trend may indicate that the leadership’s strategies are no longer effective in the current business environment.

2. Loss of Vision and Direction could indicate a Change of Leadership is required

Leadership is as much about vision as it is about execution. If the senior team seems to lack a clear, strategic direction or fails to communicate a compelling vision for the future, it may signal the need for new leadership. A fresh perspective can rejuvenate the company’s strategy and re-align the organisation with its core objectives and values.

The loss of vision and direction refers to a situation where a company no longer has a clear or coherent strategy guiding its operations, growth, and long-term objectives. This can manifest in various ways and have significant implications for the company’s success and sustainability. Below are key aspects that illustrate what loss of vision and direction entails and its potential impacts on a business:

2.1 Lack of Clear Objectives

Without a clear vision, a company might struggle to set and pursue meaningful objectives. This can lead to a lack of focus in its operations. And then, making it difficult for the business to allocate resources effectively or pursue opportunities that align with its core competencies and long-term goals.

2.2 Difficulty in Decision Making

A clear vision and direction facilitate decision-making processes by providing a framework against which options can be evaluated. Without this clarity, decision-making can become inconsistent, reactive, and lacking in strategic focus. This can lead to missed opportunities or misallocated resources.

2.3 Eroding Competitive Edge

A well-defined vision often includes elements of differentiation that set a company apart from its competitors. Losing sight of this unique value proposition can result in a business that struggles to stand out in the marketplace, affecting its ability to attract and retain customers.

2.4 Demotivation Among Employees

Vision and direction are crucial for employee motivation and engagement. They provide team members with a sense of purpose and belonging. Without a clear vision, employees may feel disconnected, unsure of their contributions towards the company’s goals, leading to lower productivity and higher turnover rates.

2.5 Misalignment of Efforts can mean a Change of Leadership is required

A strong vision ensures that all aspects of the company—from its product development and marketing strategies to its customer service and internal processes—are aligned towards a common goal. The loss of vision can lead to disjointed efforts, where departments or teams work in silos, undermining the company’s overall effectiveness and efficiency.

2.6 Strained Stakeholder Relations

Investors, partners, and customers often engage with a company based on its vision and the promise of what it aims to achieve. When a company loses its direction, it can erode trust and confidence among these key stakeholders, potentially leading to reduced investment, partnerships, and customer loyalty.

2.7 Inability to Adapt

A clear vision includes a forward-looking component, anticipating changes in the market and adapting accordingly. The loss of vision and direction can make a company less agile, slowing its response to industry trends, technological advancements, or shifts in consumer behavior, which can place it at a competitive disadvantage.

3. Resistance to Change

In today’s fast-paced world, adaptability is key. If your leadership team is resistant to change or slow to respond to industry shifts, technological advancements, or changes in consumer behaviour, it could be detrimental to your business. A leadership team that embraces change, seeks innovation, and is willing to pivot strategies when necessary is vital for long-term success.

4. Erosion of Company Culture can Result in a Change of Leadership

If there’s a noticeable decline in employee morale, engagement, or an increase in turnover, particularly among high performers, it might be a reflection of leadership issues. A change at the top can help to reset the culture, align it with the company’s values, and boost morale.

5. Deterioration in Stakeholder Confidence

Confidence from stakeholders, including investors, customers, and employees, is fundamental. If stakeholders express concerns about the company’s direction or leadership’s decisions, it’s important to take notice. Losing stakeholder confidence can have a severe impact on the company’s reputation, financial health, and operational stability.

6. Lack of Succession Planning

A forward-thinking leadership team will have a clear plan for succession to ensure the company’s resilience and continuity. If there’s a lack of focus on developing internal talent or identifying potential future leaders, it may indicate a need for change. Effective succession planning is a hallmark of robust leadership and organisational health.

Conclusion about Change of Leadership

Deciding to change your senior leadership team is not a decision to be taken lightly. It requires a thoughtful assessment of the current leadership’s effectiveness, the company’s performance, and the broader industry context. Recognising and acting upon the need for change can be a transformative step, paving the way for renewed success and growth. As such, it’s imperative for companies to remain vigilant, assessing their leadership effectiveness regularly and being prepared to make tough decisions when necessary for the greater good of the organisation.


At re:find we have been in Executive Search for over 20 years. We believe that recruitment is not a one-off transaction but rather a long-term partnership. We aim to build long-term relationships with our clients, providing ongoing support and advice to help them find and retain the best talent for their organisation.

In addition, as a business, we understand that every organisation is unique and that there is no one-size-fits-all solution when it comes to recruitment. That’s why we offer bespoke recruitment solutions that are tailored to meet the specific needs of each client. Whether you need help with a single hire or a full recruitment campaign, we can help.

We are committed to providing our clients with the highest quality service. As part of this, we ensure that we take the time to understand your organisation’s culture and values, as well as the specific skills and experience needed for each role.

For more information on our executive search practice and our CCS framework
please get in touch with our Managing Director, James Cumming.

Please visit our website to see more of our knowledge hub: https://refind.co.uk/


Recent Posts

The Impact of a New Labour Government Changes on UK Businesses: Focus on Recruitment and Leadership

read more

How to ‘Flex Work’ in the Pharmaceutical Industry?

read more

Women Leading the Way in Aviation

read more

subscribe to our blog

Join our members list
to receive the latest insights.

    Enter Your Email